Thursday 24 January 2013

Are record shops still important?

Well you wouldn't expect the answer no from me would you?! As someone who owns an independent record shop in Leeds city centre we rely on people buying physical product. And I have to say that I'm pretty positive at the moment. The huge resurgence in vinyl sales during the last few years has had a very significant impact on our ability to continue trading. The shop is now in its 28th year and half of those have been under my ownership.
Prior to buying Crash I worked as a sales rep for CBS/Sony Music calling on record shops throughout the north of England. I did 12 years on the road and loved just about every minute. Future blogs may well contain some of the stories from those days! Before my days working for a record company I had 8 years in record retail. The first four at Virgin Records, followed by a stretch of similar length at HMV.

Virgin has of course disappeared off the map, but the big worry now is that HMV may also vanish from the high street. You may think this would be a cause for celebration for an independent record retailer but it isn't. As other people have already said, HMV closing would negatively impact on the whole record industry and would probably mean fewer releases and labels going out of business. There simply aren't enough independent record shops to pick up those lost sales. (And yes, I do realise that Top Dog probably contributed to lots of independent record shops closing during the last few decades).

The perception that a piece of music has value would soon disappear if we lived in a world where downloads were the only option. Thankfully though lots of people still want to own something tangible by their favourite band or artist. We love to collect stuff, it's in the nation's DNA and there aren't many things better than a record collection (in alphabetical order of course!) so it's vital that we continue to see record shops in cities and towns across the country. There is still plenty of demand out there for CDs and LPs.

Once the HMV situation is sorted out I think the record industry should look at ways to try and ensure that shops continue to trade around the country. Encouraging people to visit bricks and mortar retailers rather than heading straight to Amazon would be good. We pay all our taxes so it's difficult to match them on price without a little help from the record companies.

Something that should definitely be looked at though is the day of the week that albums and singles are released. It has been Monday for many years now, and in the past the only option was to head to the shop on that day to pick up your new release. It used to be a very busy and exciting day for retailers. Now, because there are so many options for people that buzz has disappeared, So why not have Saturday as new release day? It's the busiest day of the week when lots of people are not at work. It could potentially bring the excitement back to new release day. And if that means that the chart is moved to Friday instead of Sunday then why not? There's nothing wrong with shaking things up now and again.

Anyway, that's enough from me for now. Thanks for reading the very first Crash Records blog.



4 comments:

  1. One question I would pose in response would be, what is the significance of having one day a week when new music is being released? I know what the significance 'used to be', but what is its relevance 'now', in the 21st century? I used to eagerly await Mondays, and head to my favourite record shops straight after school, every Monday without fail. I would love for new release day to be as important to today's youth as it was to me, but I don't think it is.

    The thing is, the charts were important in my youth. I don't think the charts are as relevant today, and without the charts, there won't be so much focus on new release day, whatever day it is. When I were a lad, it was unheard of for a single or album to be released on any day other than a Monday (I think U2 did it once, and it was a real talking point). But now, it is not as uncommon for things to be released on an 'unconventional' day.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It's only chart releases music wise that got released on a Mon you can get delivery of records any day of the week.

    A couple of things have changed the way people are alerted or hear some new music, besides what people say TOTP on a Thurs night had a huge bearing on the charts.

    Since its removal and disappearance that platform has gone for artists to have a last push.

    Do i remember singles been released on a Thursday at one point?

    Digital has changed a lot of things but physical releases are still important i buy records on vinyl always have always will but then i spent 15 years buying and selling music.

    The fact is independents especially in Leeds have continued regardless hats off to Ian who has always been a positive figure for music in this town.

    Majority of people who like to 'talk' about these subjects are keyboard warriors never supported record shops and if its free on the internet then all the better for them.

    Good read Ian.

    Andy.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for the replies chaps. The charts aren't really that significant anymore and I don't think those days will ever come back. If you worked in a record shop in the 80s and hadn't seen Top Of The Pops on Thursday you certainly knew on Friday what had been on!

    The idea is more about having a more convenient day for marketing something that is brand new that week. Record Store Day is an extreme example of how you can mobilise a lot of people to purchase limited editions and special releases. If someone came up with the suggestion to move Record Store Day from Saturday to Monday they would be laughed at.

    So why not think in terms of special packaging or limited edition new releases that become available on that first Saturday of release? For example the new Bowie album gets released and let's say there are 5,000 picture disc LPs manufactured. A decent percentage of that stock is put into record shops around the country. They are all told that the earliest on sale time is 9:00am on the Saturday of release. People would make the effort to get to their nearest record shop to buy one.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yes, I see your points. In the 21st century, if people want that collectors edition on the day it is released (if that day is a Monday) and a lot of people can't get in to a shop until the Saturday, then those fans may buy online. But if Saturday was *the* day, then yes I can see it could potentially turn every Saturday into a mini RSD.

    ReplyDelete